🍪Crumbl Tracker

Rarity leaderboard

Rarity is appearances ÷ eligible weeks, where eligible weeks runs from a flavor's first-ever appearance through the latest tracked menu. A flavor that showed up 3 times across 40 eligible weeks scores 7.5% — lower is rarer.

Flavors must have ≥ 8eligible weeks before they rank, otherwise a brand-new debut would automatically be “legendary.” Bucket cutoffs: <8% Legendary, <20% Rare, <40% Uncommon, else Common.

45 weeks tracked · 182 unique flavors · 100 one-hit wonders

Rarest flavors

Fewest appearances per eligible week

  1. 1
    Maple Bacon Cookie
    Maple Bacon Cookie
    Legendary · 2.4% · 1/41 wks· Only 10/13/25
  2. 2
    🍪
    Apple Cider Donut Cookie
    Legendary · 2.5% · 1/40 wks· Only 10/20/25
  3. 3
    🍪
    Candy Corn Cookie
    Legendary · 2.5% · 1/40 wks· Only 10/20/25
  4. 4
    🍪
    Halloween Sugar Cookie
    Legendary · 2.6% · 1/39 wks· Only 10/27/25
  5. 5
    Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie
    Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie
    Legendary · 2.6% · 1/39 wks· Only 10/27/25
  6. 6
    Brownie Batter Cookie
    Brownie Batter Cookie
    Legendary · 2.6% · 1/39 wks· Only 10/27/25
  7. 7
    🍪
    Gingerbread Cheesecake
    Legendary · 3.0% · 1/33 wks· Only 12/8/25
  8. 8
    🍪
    Birthday Cake Cookie
    ft. Oreos
    Legendary · 3.0% · 1/33 wks· Only 12/8/25
  9. 9
    🍪
    Peppermint Chocolate Chip Cookie
    Legendary · 3.0% · 1/33 wks· Only 12/8/25
  10. 10
    🍪
    White Chocolate Peppermint Cookie
    Legendary · 3.1% · 1/32 wks· Only 12/15/25
  11. 11
    🍪
    Hot Cocoa Cookie
    Legendary · 3.1% · 1/32 wks· Only 12/15/25
  12. 12
    Eggnog Cookie
    Eggnog Cookie
    Legendary · 3.2% · 1/31 wks· Only 12/22/25
  13. 13
    🍪
    Gingerbread Cookie
    Legendary · 3.2% · 1/31 wks· Only 12/22/25
  14. 14
    Peppermint Bark Cookie
    Peppermint Bark Cookie
    Legendary · 3.2% · 1/31 wks· Only 12/22/25
  15. 15
    Sugar Cookie
    Sugar Cookie
    ft. MOTHER’S REINDEER GAMES
    Legendary · 3.2% · 1/31 wks· Only 12/22/25
  16. 16
    Peanut Butter Cup Brownie
    Peanut Butter Cup Brownie
    ft. REESE’S
    Legendary · 3.8% · 1/26 wks· Only 1/26/26
  17. 17
    Dubai Chocolate Cookie
    Dubai Chocolate Cookie
    Legendary · 3.8% · 1/26 wks· Only 1/26/26
  18. 18
    Fudge Brownie Football Cookie
    Fudge Brownie Football Cookie
    Legendary · 3.8% · 1/26 wks· Only 1/26/26
  19. 19
    Salted Caramel Cheesecake Cookie
    Salted Caramel Cheesecake Cookie
    Legendary · 4.0% · 1/25 wks· Only 2/2/26
  20. 20
    Strawberry Heart Cake
    Strawberry Heart Cake
    Legendary · 4.0% · 1/25 wks· Only 2/2/26
  21. 21
    🍪
    Valentine’s M&M’S® Cookie
    Legendary · 4.0% · 1/25 wks· Only 2/2/26
  22. 22
    Dubai Chocolate Strawberry Brownie
    Dubai Chocolate Strawberry Brownie
    Legendary · 4.0% · 1/25 wks· Only 2/2/26
  23. 23
    🍪
    Pink Velvet Cookie
    Legendary · 4.2% · 1/24 wks· Only 2/9/26
  24. 24
    Buckeye Brownie Cookie
    Buckeye Brownie Cookie
    Legendary · 4.2% · 1/24 wks· Only 2/9/26
  25. 25
    Raspberry Cheesecake
    Raspberry Cheesecake
    Legendary · 4.2% · 1/24 wks· Only 2/9/26
  26. 26
    🍪
    Red Velvet Heart Cake
    Legendary · 4.2% · 1/24 wks· Only 2/9/26
  27. 27
    🍪
    Pumpkin Spice Cookie
    Legendary · 4.3% · 2/46 wks· 9/8/25 → 9/29/25
  28. 28
    🍪
    Raspberry White Chocolate Cookie
    Legendary · 4.3% · 1/23 wks· Only 2/16/26
  29. 29
    Chocolate Hazelnut Cheesecake
    Chocolate Hazelnut Cheesecake
    ft. NUTELLA
    Legendary · 4.3% · 2/46 wks· 9/8/25 → 3/9/26
  30. 30
    Brown Sugar Cinnamon Cookie
    Brown Sugar Cinnamon Cookie
    ft. Pop Tarts
    Legendary · 4.3% · 2/46 wks· 9/8/25 → 3/9/26

Fan favorites

Most appearances all-time

  1. 1
    Caramel Shortbread Cookie
    Caramel Shortbread Cookie
    ft. TWIX
    Uncommon · 21.3% · 10/47 wks· 9/1/25 → 7/6/26
  2. 2
    Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
    Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
    ft. REESE’S
    Rare · 15.6% · 7/45 wks· 9/15/25 → 6/15/26
  3. 3
    Banana Bread Cookie
    Banana Bread Cookie
    Rare · 16.2% · 6/37 wks· 11/10/25 → 5/11/26
  4. 4
    Churro Cookie
    Churro Cookie
    Rare · 15.8% · 6/38 wks· 11/3/25 → 6/22/26
  5. 5
    Birthday Cake Cookie
    Birthday Cake Cookie
    ft. OREO
    Rare · 12.8% · 6/47 wks· 9/1/25 → 7/6/26
  6. 6
    Confetti Cake Cookie
    Confetti Cake Cookie
    Rare · 17.2% · 5/29 wks· 1/5/26 → 4/13/26
  7. 7
    Blue Monster Cookie
    Blue Monster Cookie
    ft. CHIPS AHOY!
    Rare · 10.6% · 5/47 wks· 9/1/25 → 5/18/26
  8. 8
    Key Lime Pie Cookie
    Key Lime Pie Cookie
    Rare · 14.8% · 4/27 wks· 1/19/26 → 4/13/26
  9. 9
    Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Cup
    Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry Cup
    New · 66.7% · 4/6 wks· 6/15/26 → 7/6/26
  10. 10
    Sugar Cookie
    Sugar Cookie
    ft. Mother’s Circus Animal
    Rare · 8.9% · 4/45 wks· 9/15/25 → 4/6/26
  11. 11
    🍪
    Chocolate Strawberry Cup
    New · 66.7% · 4/6 wks· 6/15/26 → 7/6/26
  12. 12
    Strawberry Milk Cookie
    Strawberry Milk Cookie
    ft. Pirouline
    Rare · 9.3% · 4/43 wks· 9/29/25 → 3/30/26
  13. 13
    Caramel Apple Cookie
    Caramel Apple Cookie
    Rare · 9.3% · 4/43 wks· 9/29/25 → 6/22/26
  14. 14
    Peanut Butter Cup Brownie Cookie
    Peanut Butter Cup Brownie Cookie
    ft. Reese’s
    Rare · 12.5% · 4/32 wks· 12/15/25 → 5/25/26
  15. 15
    Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie
    Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie
    Rare · 14.3% · 4/28 wks· 1/12/26 → 5/25/26
  16. 16
    Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cookie
    Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cookie
    Rare · 16.7% · 4/24 wks· 2/9/26 → 5/4/26
  17. 17
    Cookie Dough Cookie
    Cookie Dough Cookie
    Rare · 14.3% · 4/28 wks· 1/12/26 → 5/11/26
  18. 18
    🍪
    Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie
    ft. Reese’s
    Rare · 8.5% · 4/47 wks· 9/1/25 → 3/16/26
  19. 19
    Biscoff Tres Leches Cake
    Biscoff Tres Leches Cake
    Rare · 11.5% · 3/26 wks· 1/26/26 → 4/27/26
  20. 20
    🍪
    Salted Caramel Cookie
    Rare · 11.5% · 3/26 wks· 1/26/26 → 4/13/26
  21. 21
    Cake Batter Cookie Thins
    Cake Batter Cookie Thins
    New · 50.0% · 3/6 wks· 6/15/26 → 7/20/26
  22. 22
    Biscoff Cheesecake
    Biscoff Cheesecake
    Legendary · 7.9% · 3/38 wks· 11/3/25 → 5/25/26
  23. 23
    S’mores Cookie Thins
    S’mores Cookie Thins
    Uncommon · 30.0% · 3/10 wks· 5/18/26 → 7/20/26
  24. 24
    🍪
    Chocolate Crumb Cookie
    ft. OREO
    Legendary · 6.7% · 3/45 wks· 9/15/25 → 12/1/25
  25. 25
    Chocolate Chip Cookie Thins
    Chocolate Chip Cookie Thins
    Uncommon · 33.3% · 3/9 wks· 5/25/26 → 7/20/26
  26. 26
    🍪
    Red Velvet Cheesecake Cookie
    Rare · 8.1% · 3/37 wks· 11/10/25 → 3/2/26
  27. 27
    🍪
    Chocolate Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookie
    ft. OREO
    Legendary · 6.8% · 3/44 wks· 9/22/25 → 3/23/26
  28. 28
    Biscoff White Chip Cookie
    Biscoff White Chip Cookie
    Rare · 11.1% · 3/27 wks· 1/19/26 → 5/4/26
  29. 29
    🍪
    Cookies & Cream Cake
    ft. OREO
    Legendary · 6.8% · 3/44 wks· 9/22/25 → 3/23/26
  30. 30
    Strawberry Shortcake
    Strawberry Shortcake
    Uncommon · 20.0% · 3/15 wks· 4/13/26 → 6/29/26

Fresh debuts

Debuted in the last 8 weeks — excluded from rarity rankings until they age.