Weeks tracked
58
Unique flavors
240
One-hit wonders
143
Partner collabs
34
This Week
Oct 19 – 25, 2026
9 flavors · 3 debuts · 0 comebacks · 6 returning
Banana Bread Cookie11/10/25 → 10/19/26 · 7×
Cereal Milk Cookieft. Fruity PEBBLESOnly 10/19/26 · 1×NEW
Chocolate Chip Cookie7/27/26 → 10/19/26 · 13×
Chocolate Chip Cookie Thins5/25/26 → 10/19/26 · 4×
Cookies & Cream White Chip Cookie9/14/26 → 10/19/26 · 2×
Dubai-Style Chocolate Brownie9/14/26 → 10/19/26 · 3×
Original M&M'S® CookieOnly 10/19/26 · 1×NEW
Pink Sugar Cookie7/27/26 → 10/19/26 · 12×
Tres Leches CakeOnly 10/19/26 · 1×NEW
Rarest flavors
Fewest appearances per eligible week
Maple Bacon CookieLegendary · 1.9% · 1/54 wks· Only 10/13/25- 🍪Apple Cider Donut CookieLegendary · 1.9% · 1/53 wks· Only 10/20/25
- 🍪Candy Corn CookieLegendary · 1.9% · 1/53 wks· Only 10/20/25
- 🍪Halloween Sugar CookieLegendary · 1.9% · 1/52 wks· Only 10/27/25
Pumpkin Cheesecake CookieLegendary · 1.9% · 1/52 wks· Only 10/27/25- 🍪Gingerbread CheesecakeLegendary · 2.2% · 1/46 wks· Only 12/8/25
Fan favorites
Highest appearance rate (per eligible week)
- Chocolate Chip CookieClassic · 100.0% · 13/13 wks· 7/27/26 → 10/19/26
- Pink Sugar CookieClassic · 92.3% · 12/13 wks· 7/27/26 → 10/19/26
Dubai-Style Chocolate Strawberry CupCommon · 21.1% · 4/19 wks· 6/15/26 → 7/6/26- 🍪Chocolate Strawberry CupCommon · 21.1% · 4/19 wks· 6/15/26 → 7/6/26
Caramel Shortbread Cookieft. TWIXCommon · 18.3% · 11/60 wks· 9/1/25 → 10/12/26- Chocolate Chip Cookie ThinsCommon · 18.2% · 4/22 wks· 5/25/26 → 10/19/26
Fresh debuts
Debuted in the last 8 weeks — too new to rankHow rarity works
Rarity = appearances ÷ eligible weeks, where eligible weeks counts every week from a flavor's debut through the latest tracked menu. Lower score = rarer. Flavors need 8 eligible weeks before they qualify — otherwise a brand-new debut would automatically be “legendary.” Buckets: <3% Legendary, <8% Rare, <15% Uncommon, else Common.
Debuts are first-ever appearances. Comebacks are flavors Crumbl tagged “NEW” this week even though they’ve been on the menu before. Returning is everything else — flavors that were on prior menus but Crumbl didn’t flag as new. Together the three add up to the week’s total.